WNW: Spock vs Spock

Fascinating.

BSG vs B5: A Nerd-Off

Pardon me while I phone this in.

Inspired by Salem's comment that "I'm a sucker for the end-to-tail flips the Vipers can do. Those have to be the most maneuverable fighters I have ever seen," I present to you the following nerd-off question:

Who would win?

The Viper Mk. II
Race	Colonial
Type	Military
FTL	No
Propulsion	1 x Voram VM2-D15 upper turbothrust engine, 2x Voram VM3-D22 turbothrust engines, 2x reverse thrust motors: RCS points
Crew	1 pilot
Capacity
Role	Space superiority fighter
Weapons	2 Kinetic Energy Weapon, missiles
Armaments	2 x MEC-A6 30mm Thraxon forward-firing kinetic energy weapons (KEW) mounted in the wing roots with 800 round magazine, Dorsal storage bay for 8 x HD-70 Lightning Javelin missiles (optional 50 megaton nuclear warhead)[1], Weapon hardpoints for mounting missiles / munitions pods, etc. under the wings
Status	Obsolete / In current Colonial service
Other Images	More images...
Dimensions
Length	(8.4082m)[2]
Height	(2.7247m)[2][3]
Wingspan	(4.7168m)[2]

OR


The SA-23 Mitchell-Hyundyne Starfury

SA-23 Mitchell-Hyundyne Starfury
Status:	Active
Afilliation:	EarthForce
Class:	Aurora
Length:	9.56m
Mass:	48mt
Crew:	1
Engines:	4 Copeland ion engines 4 vaporized solid propellant engines
Weapons:	4 40mm pulse cannons 2 30mm pulse cannons (rear)
Defenses:	4.2cm re-inforced hull 1 grappling claw 1 cutting laser
Power:	3 fusion batteries

(Data and images shamelessly swiped from The Battlestar Wiki and The Babylon Project.)

Vote in the poll, argue your point in the comments section... basically, fight each other for my amusement.

EDIT: The votes are in, and the Viper wins, 8 votes to 6. It was a close one!